The
durability of anthracite filter media has been described
by many methods each of which has its strengths and weaknesses.
| 1 |
Hardness |
Moh Scale |
| 2 |
Grindability |
Hardgrove Index |
| 3 |
Crushing Modulus |
Pressure |
| 4 |
Attrition Loss |
Loss per 100 hours Backwashing |
- Hardness on the Moh Scales compares the hardness of
anthracite with other minerals. An average of many comparisons
are made to obtain a value. The higher the value the harder
the anthracite. The Moh's hardness test is a very subjective test.
The resulting minimum value should be above 2.8.
- The hardness of the anthracite may be high on the Moh scale,
but if it fractures easily it will appear soft. The Hardgrove Index
of Grindability goes some way to address this. Basically the
anthracite is hit a set number of times by steel balls and the
its degradation measured. An figure is then calculated to give
the Hardgrove Index. The lower the figure the less friable the
anthracite. No figure is given by any standard but a reasonable
result would be between 50 and 80 Hardgrove.
- Neither hardness or grindability completely describes the
condition of anthracite in a filter. The Crushing Modulus was
developed to over come this. In this test anthracite is crushed
in a test chamber and a figure calculated from the results.
The result should have a minimum value of 105 bar. The
draw back of this method is that a different value is obtained
for the same anthracite but of different hydraulic size. The
smaller the hydraulic size the higher the Crushing Modulus.
- The backwash test is probably the best way to determine
the durability of the anthracite as it mimics the actual conditions
under which the anthracite will operate. This test determines
the loss of anthracite due to particle breakage over a period
of 100 hours backwashing [approx 3 years of operation].
It should be noted, however, that the test cannot be just
carried out for 1 hour and the results multiplied by 100 as
during the first period of the test most of the sharp corners and
edges of the anthracite will break off. This result should not be
greater than 5% loss over 100 hours
|